Theodorus William John Wylie is buried at Woodlands Cemetery, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.
Washington a Christian: A Discourse Preached February 23, 1862, in the First Reformed Presbyterian Church, Philadelphia (1862)
Fiftieth Anniversary of the Ordination of Rev. T.W.J. Wylie, D.D. and of His Installation as Pastor of the Wylie Memorial Presbyterian Church, Formerly the First Reformed Presbyterian Congregation of Philadelphia, Held October 22nd, 25th and 26th, 1893 (1893)